Geoffrey Miller: What Japan’s foreign policy shifts mean for New Zealand

Geoffrey Miller: What Japan’s foreign policy shifts mean for New Zealand

Japan is a country on the move.

Since World War II, Tokyo has largely been happy to outsource its security needs to Washington.

But this is now changing to a more equal partnership.

On Friday, Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida called his country’s alliance with the United States ‘stronger than ever’.

For his part, US President Joe Biden, who hosted Kishida at the White House, said the United States was ‘fully, thoroughly, completely committed to the alliance’ with Japan.

The words from Kishida and Biden might seem like the usual diplomatic niceties, but behind the smiles from the two leaders was a quantum shift in Tokyo’s foreign policy positioning.

The war’s legacy and subsequent 1947 pacifist constitution help to explain why Japan has until now preferred its military to keep a low profile – a deal which has come at a bargain price.

For decades, Japan’s defence budget has hovered around 1 per cent of its Gross Domestic Product (GDP), well below the levels of other G7 nations.

Japan has traditionally invested less in its military than even New Zealand – which currently spends around 1.5 per cent of its GDP on its defence force.

But this won’t be the case for much longer.

Under a new security blueprint unveiled by Fumio Kishida’s government in mid-December, Tokyo is pledging to double its defence spending to at least 2 per cent of GDP by 2027.

Over the past fortnight, the Japanese Prime Minister has embarked on something of a sales pitch for the new plans by visiting each of the other six countries in the G7.

The tour wrapped up on Friday when Kishida stopped at the White House to meet with Joe Biden.

Tokyo’s more hawkish turn will be music to Washington’s ears.

The plans see Japan buying up advanced weaponry – including long-range Tomahawk cruise missiles from the US – and spending more on developing hypersonic and cybersecurity technology.

And one does not need to look far to find out why.

Japan’s new National Security Strategy (NSS) openly calls out China, describing Beijing a ‘matter of serious concern for Japan’ and the ‘greatest strategic challenge’ to the country’s security.

The NSS also alleges China is developing its ‘strategic ties’ with Russia and is seeking to ‘challenge the international order’.

While similar characterisations have become commonplace in US security documents, they represent a sea change for the previously pacifist Japan.

Tokyo’s dramatic shifts are likely to have ramifications for New Zealand, which receives a special mention in the companion National Defence Strategy that was also released in December.

The new security documents make clear that Japan expects its own changes will come as part of a team effort by ‘like-minded countries’.

New Zealand is currently undertaking a review of its own defence policy, which was launched following Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and after Wellington published an unusually hawkish defence assessment at the end of 2021.

That document called China’s rise the ‘major driver of geopolitical change’ and said Beijing was ‘seeking to reshape the international system’.

The desire for multilateral cooperation with countries such as New Zealand emerged as a major theme in conversations with Japanese diplomats and experts when I visited Tokyo as a guest of Japan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs just before Christmas.

One foreign ministry official told me he believed 2022 had been a ‘transformative’ year for Japan-New Zealand relations and said New Zealand had ‘embraced’ the concept of the ‘free and open Indo-Pacific’.

Asked whether Japan wanted New Zealand to join its side, the diplomat said that decision was up to the New Zealand people – but he believed ‘like-minded countries can make the right choices’.

New Zealand’s strengths in the Pacific are an obvious attraction to Japan as part of the strategy to contain China. The official said Japan was still ‘shocked’ by Beijing’s security deal with Solomon Islands that was signed early in 2022, calling it a ‘big wake-up call’ that reinforced the need for Tokyo to win ‘hearts and minds’ in Pacific countries.

New Zealand Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern visited Japan last April to meet with her counterpart Fumio Kishida on her first foreign trip since the beginning of the Covid-19 pandemic.

After their meeting, Ardern called Japan ‘one of New Zealand’s closest and most important partners in the Indo-Pacific’. Both countries pledged to step up an existing Japan New Zealand Strategic Cooperative Partnership and signed an agreement to share security-related classified information.

The joint statement referred several times to the need for the Indo-Pacific to remain ‘free and open’ – a phrase squarely aimed at Beijing that was popularised by the late Shinzo Abe, the former Japanese prime minister who was assassinated last July.

Like New Zealand, Japan is highly dependent on trade with China. 23 per cent of Japan’s exports go to China every year, and Japan also relies on China for a quarter of its imports.

For New Zealand, the reliance on China is even greater: 32 per cent of New Zealand’s exports are sent to China annually.

When asked about how the apparent trade vs. security dilemma could be untangled, Japanese observers I spoke with were generally sympathetic to New Zealand’s plight.

One analyst bluntly said there was ‘no answer’ to economic dependence on China and that Japan’s trade diversification efforts were of an ‘incremental’ nature.

Another academic noted similarities between New Zealand’s position and many Southeast Asian countries, which are also heavily reliant on the Chinese market.

Both experts saw the current geopolitical situation as being long-term in nature – akin to the Cold War – and believed the issues would not go away anytime soon.

Is there a third option for New Zealand to avoid heavily aligning itself with one side or the other in the current bout of Great Power competition – and instead play the role of an intermediary between the two camps?

Noting the loss of Sweden and Finland as neutral countries in 2022, the academic said there was certainly ‘value’ in the idea of New Zealand playing the role of go-between – but it would take ‘strong and clever leadership’ to pull it off.

And it would not necessarily be any cheaper: neutral countries such as Finland and Switzerland still maintained sizeable defence budgets throughout the Cold War.

But the academic pointed to Ireland’s role as the architect of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT), signed at the height of the Cold War in 1968, showed what could be achieved: ‘New Zealand could have its own moment in history’.

Despite vast differences in size, culture and history, there are similarities between Japan and New Zealand that extend well beyond rugby and earthquakes.

For different reasons, both countries have traditionally paid close attention to nuclear disarmament issues. New Zealand has maintained a nuclear-free policy since 1984.

Tokyo’s decision to take a more realist approach may resonate particularly well with Wellington, which in recent decades has generally tended to tread a more doveish line than other Western countries.

Another Japanese commentator told me he believed New Zealand was a ‘more pacifist country than we are, than we were’.

Change has not come easily to Japan – and the new military and security strategy is not without its critics inside the country.

The massive cost of the arms build-up will come at the cost of matching tax hikes.

Ultimately, Wellington will need to make its own foreign policy decisions, in its own interests.

But whatever the future holds, Japan will be a country for New Zealand to watch.

Geoffrey Miller is the Democracy Project’s geopolitical analyst and writes on current New Zealand foreign policy and related geopolitical issues. He has lived in Germany and the Middle East and is a learner of Arabic and Russian. He is currently working on a PhD on New Zealand’s relations with the Gulf states. Disclosure: Geoffrey Miller visited Tokyo as a guest of Japan’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

This article can be republished under a Creative Commons CC BY-ND 4.0  license. Attributions should include a link to the Democracy Project.  

Featured image credit: By 内閣官房内閣広報室, CC BY 4.0,


Other items of interest and importance today

Rob Stock (Stuff): Lifting the pension age plunged a legion of UK grannies into poverty, we must not follow suit
Brian Easton (Pundit): The Economy In 2023?
Benn Bathgate (Stuff): More than 400 Kiwis dead at work in a decade, but 165 WorkSafe prosecutions
Tamsyn Parker (Herald): KiwiSaver power list: Who’s really managing your money?(paywalled)
Anna Rawhiti-Connell (Spinoff): A dollar each way: the economy in 2023
Rob Stock (Stuff): BNZ has brought back sale targets for frontline staff, four years after they were abandoned
Tom Pullar-Strecker (Stuff): Government says carbon dioxide supplies being rationed and ‘prioritised’
Esther Taunton (Stuff): Supermarkets paying 24% more for fresh produce as suppliers’ costs keep rising
Daniel Dunkely (BusinessDesk): Screen grant review leaves NZ film industry in ‘limbo’(paywalled)

Max Rashbrooke (Stuff): Is the electorate in the mood for radical changes?
Sasha Borissenko: Now That’s What I Call Legislation Vol. 2 (paywalled)
Bridie Witton (Stuff): David Seymour: A vote for ACT will keep National on the right
Aaron Dahman (Newstalk ZB): Govt forced to spend millions of dollars on empty Ministry of Education building
Michael Neilson (Herald): ‘Don’t give up’: Act MP Toni Severin on her dyslexia and being a politician
Adam Pearse (Herald): Green MP Golriz Ghahraman challenges other parties to empower disabled in Parliament
Steven Cowan: Jacinda Ardern: The victim of “misogynistic attitudes and beliefs”?
Thomas Manch (Stuff): Summer off politics: National MP Simeon Brown’s family-focused summer break

Tom Dillane (Herald): Wayne Brown’s ‘staggering’ $123k legal bill, plus his $5k a week chief of staff
Todd Niall (Stuff): Wayne Brown’s first 100 days: Auckland’s chief grinch or fiscal saviour?
RNZ: Council-managed buses carry National Party advertising
Kim Knight (Herald): How much should Auckland Art Gallery pay for Frida Kahlo, Gilbert & George and more? (paywalled)
Steven Walton (Stuff): Christchurch’s $683m Te Kaha stadium starts to take shape
Tina Law (Stuff): Compost plant not to blame for ‘vile stench’ that blankets suburb, council says

Charlie Mitchell (Stuff): Why Wellington should no longer be the capital of New Zealand
Peter Dunne (Stuff): What Wellington needs to do if it wants to be a credible capital
Jonathan Milne (Newsroom): Socks, frocks and saving Wellington from self-indulgence

Janet Wilson (Stuff): New Zealand’s outrageous approach to injustice
Herald Editorial: Wrongful convictions must be compensated (paywalled)
Mike White and Blair Ensor (Stuff): Police officers surprised at appointment of former top cop to new role

Newshub: Election 2023: Political parties called upon to introduce ‘pollution-busting home reno programme’ after election
Torika Tokalau (Stuff): New Zealand’s first multigenerational state homes a Pasifika game-changer
Frances Chin (Stuff): Mana whenua occupiers denounce proposed $350m housing plan
Anne Gibson (Herald): Orewa to Beach Haven: Residents battle against Auckland housing intensification (paywalled)
Geraden Cann (Stuff): No tenants paid in Mauri Ora case involving filthy rental properties
Geraden Cann (Stuff): High house prices resulting in prenups and ‘contracting out’ boom
David Chaston (Interest): We are still a long way from winding back the outrageous gains that began in 2020

Michael Neilson (Herald): How NZ’s $1.3b climate change fund is being spent on the Pacific, and why advocates are keeping ‘close watch’ (paywalled)
Marc Daalder (Newsroom): In 2023, climate will get political

Michael Neilson (Herald): Tertiary fees-free policy: Wealthier students benefit most after four years of scheme
RNZ: Home childcare organisation Porse has nine licences temporarily suspended
Ripu Bhatia (Stuff): Prejudice high on Māori parents’ worry list for their children, survey finds
RNZ: Youth crisis helpline braced for influx of callers anxious about school return

Olivia Caldwell (Stuff): Three rodeo deaths in three days sparks renewed call for a ban
Baz Macdonald (Re:News): Three animals died at NZ rodeo events this summer

Fran O’Sullivan (Herald): Big trade agenda for Damien O’Connor at Davos (paywalled)
Jamie Ensor (Newshub): Free Trade Agreement: New Zealand lamb at centre of furore in United Kingdom Parliament
RNZ: Plea for more support for Ukrainians in New Zealand: ‘Most don’t have a home to go back to’
Fran O’Sullivan (Herald): High-profile Russians banned from Auckland Asia-Pacific business meeting (paywalled)
Charlie Gates (Stuff): ‘Thanks for the money, we’re going to rescue some people’: Missing aid worker Andrew Bagshaw caught on film
RNZ: Ukraine conflict: Fellow aid worker keeps faith Andrew Bagshaw will be found alive

Maryana Garcia (Rotorua Daily Post): Te Whatu Ora Lakes spends $41.7m on mental health services in one year
Thomas Cranmer: Covid and our Kiwi Kids – Part 1
Siouxsie Wiles (Stuff): When it comes to Covid, a name can be important
ODT: ‘Scary’: patients turned away
Niva Chittock (RNZ): Gang members block Christchurch Hospital parking, intimidate public
RNZ: Group therapy has high success rate, with services in high demand
Samuel Wat (RNZ): ‘So many obstacles’: Struggles getting mpox vaccine booking
RNZ: $1.4m research grant puts opioid addiction in frame

Paula Penfold (Stuff): Abuse of journalists shows how ugly our civil discourse has become
Ben Leahy (Herald): Census collectors to carry panic alarms amid safety fears over anti-government backlash
Natasha Hamilton-Hart (Open Inquiry): Sex, lies and the census
Steve Kilgallon (Stuff): The $1 million library that never really opened… appears to close for good
James Halpin (Stuff): Aviation authority hired second person linked to far-right group Action Zealandia
Steven Joyce (Herald): The job of the Covid inquiry (paywalled)
RNZ: Catholic Church doing opposite of public statements on abuse safeguarding – advocate
Alex Penk: Free speech is increasingly important in our symbolic culture
Jenny Nicholls (Stuff): Tangled copyright law denying public access to works they’ve a right to see
Herald: NZTA receives record number of complaints about potholes damaging cars
Jo Lines-MacKenzie (Stuff): Pothole nation – big fix for pockmarked state highway network
Andrew McRae (RNZ): Returned and Services Association struggling financially as it faces modernising, president says